Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Betsy Warrior's avatar

Although the advertisement about Saudi Arabia oil makes a very valid point about how that murderous regime deprives people of their rights, especially women, the ad may be a cover for something else disastrous like expanding oil, coal and gas exploration and mining in Canada and the US further polluting the rivers, streams, and atmosphere. Also the "hot" comment sounds kinda pornish creepy .

Expand full comment
Ollie Parks's avatar

Rebel News - I like the sound of it! It has the ring of freedom.

If you want to see what captured news looks like, here's a choice passage from a recent piece of Washington Post sympathy/outrage reporting on a mother-trans daughter combo who violated Florida's ban on boys in girls'-only sports. In Florida, it is the school district that's punished if a boy who identifies as a girl gets onto a team with real girls. Since the mom in this story was both instrumental in making it possible for her former son/current daughter to be on the team and an employee of the district, the school district brought disciplinary proceedings against the mother. Much drama ensued.

The story would not have been complete without some mention of the ban itself:

"Over the next few years, Florida and two dozen other states passed nearly identical bans on trans girls in sports. Many Republican lawmakers spoke about trans athletes as if they were all the same — tall and muscular, physically dominant, grown men cross-dressing for the sake of a secondary school athletic win. The bill sponsors didn’t mention trans girls who never went through puberty. They hardly ever talked about children like Elizabeth who tried and failed to make a seventh grade team. By 2023, multiple polls, including one by The Post and KFF, found that two-thirds of Americans agreed that trans girls should not be allowed to play girls sports."

It is conceivable the account could have been more biased and incomplete, but then even the Post would not have been able to get away with running it.

As I said in my letter to the editor of the Post:

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

It does a gross disservice to readers to present the case for the ban using only unattributed second-hand hyperbole from unnamed Republican politicians: "Many Republican lawmakers spoke about trans athletes as if they were all the same — tall and muscular, physically dominant, grown men cross-dressing for the sake of a secondary school athletic win."

The author of this piece is the accomplished Queer reporter Casey Parks, who the Post describes as a "Staff reporter covering LGBTQ issues." She has built a career as a cheerleader for sexual and gender minorities. Her treatment of this topic reflects an undeniable trans bias. The reference to a poll showing "two-thirds of Americans agreed that trans girls should not be allowed to play girls sports" sure looks like an editor's clumsy attempt after the fact to counter the bias. It was not effective, but the way.

What else accounts for the omission of the female point of view on males in women's sports? In the real world, the males who are pushing teen girls off the winners' podium are not "tall and muscular, physically dominant, grown men cross-dressing for the sake of a secondary school athletic win." They're high school teen boys with a teen male's physiological advantage over girls. The bans are in place to make sure that a girl athlete's years of training and athletic achievement don't go down the toilet when a boy unfairly defeats her. It isn't just the girl's self-esteem that's harmed. Her athletic career may suffer and she may lose out on college scholarships.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I communicated my dissent in a letter to the editor because the piece was one of the very few that was not accompanied by a comments section.

The whole story ("Her trans daughter made the volleyball team. Then an armed officer showed up.") is available behind a paywall here: https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/interactive/2024/trans-sports-girls-florida-bans/?itid=sr_1_d6ff3571-c407-46c6-9616-6f15abf517df

Here's the Post's profile of Queer author and trans collaborator Casey Parks: https://www.washingtonpost.com/people/casey-parks/

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts